The Anthology
Our Cookies
Welcome to The Anthology—our ever-growing collection of Batch & Bard cookies. Like any great library, our shelves are always evolving. While this gallery showcases the stories we've baked so far, our weekly menu changes, so not every cookie shown is available at all times. Visit our Current Menu to browse this week's featured collection, build your box, and place your order before the next chapter begins.
Poe's Velvet Masquerade
$4.00A red velvet cookie baked with dark brown sugar for depth, folded with semi-sweet chocolate chunks and cream cheese chips and topped with a generous drizzle of melted cream cheese chips. Soft, decadent and layered.
Byron's Sweet Ruin
$4.00Reckless decadence in every bite.
A decadent cookies & cream cookie packed with Oreos and chunks of Hershey's cookies & cream bars, baked into a rich swirl of creamy crunch and white chocolate chaos.
Plath's Midnight Chorus
$4.00Indulgence, composed in layers.
A triple chocolate cookie composed of rich cocoa dough folded with white chocolate chunks, semisweet chocolate pieces, and mini milk chocolate chips. Deep, velvety, and intensely layered.
Millay's Renaissance
$4.00Because some cravings are worth the fall — and the rise.
Built on a graham cracker base, layered with chocolate chips and toasted marshmallow, then baked until golden and molten: crisp, gooey and rich in every bite.
Clifton's Homage
$4.00Made for this moment.
Soft, golden coffee cake cookie infused with brown sugar, warm cinnamon, and a hint of vanilla, crowned with a brown sugar streusel and a drizzle of vanilla bean icing — a sweet celebration in every bite, rising with quiet joy.
Wilde's Earnest
$4.00Because restraint is overrated.
Browned butter forms the base of this deeply flavorful cookie, studded with dark chocolate and handcrafted toffee, then finished with flakey sea salt. Decadent, complex, and unapologetically rich.
Vonnegut's Sweet Absurdity
$4.00Nonsense, but make it delicious.
An absurdly indulgent peanut butter cookie loaded with brown sugar, peanut butter, peanut butter chips, mini peanut butter cups and mini chocolate chips. Thick, rich, and delightfully chaotic — so it goes.
Shelley's Creation
$4.00An experiment in indulgence.
An oversized, decadently rich chocolate chip cookie made with deeply browned butter, dark brown sugar, and fragrant vanilla, packed with both mini and classic chocolate chips.
By purchasing, you agree to the following terms:
Batch & Bard entrusts each order to careful hands and considered packaging before it leaves our kitchen. We are not responsible for lost, delayed, or damaged shipments that may occur in transit with the shipping carrier.
All orders are baked fresh to order and dispatched the following Monday or Tuesday after purchase.
Allergies: All goods are prepared in a single kitchen environment and we cannot guarantee the absence of cross-contamination. Batch & Bard assumes no liability for allergic reactions. Our kitchen handles wheat, eggs, dairy, and soy, and also makes products with peanuts and tree nuts.
Cottage Food Notice: Produced in a cottage food operation not subject to Florida's food safety inspection regulations.
All sales are final.
Stay in the story
Join our email list
Be first to know about new flavors, seasonal boxes, and limited drops.